BCBS Letter of Medical Necessity Template 2025 [Free Download]

The BCBS Medical Necessity Challenge

Unlike other insurers, Blue Cross Blue Shield is a federation of 34 independent companies:

• Anthem BCBS (14 states)
• Premera Blue Cross (WA, AK)
• Horizon BCBS (NJ)
• CareFirst (MD, DC, VA)
• BCBS of Michigan, Illinois, Texas, Florida, etc.

Each company has different:

• Medical necessity criteria
• Coverage policies
• Documentation requirements
• Appeal processes

This means a medical necessity letter for Anthem in California must reference different policies than one for BCBS of Texas.

What Is Medical Necessity (BCBS Definition)?

For comprehensive guidance on crafting effective medical necessity letters across all insurers, see our complete medical necessity justification letter guide.

BCBS defines "medically necessary" services as those that are:

1. Appropriate for the symptoms, diagnosis, or treatment of the condition
2. Provided for the diagnosis or direct care and treatment of the condition
3. Within standards of good medical practice in the medical community
4. Not primarily for the convenience of the patient or provider
5. The most appropriate supply or level of service that can safely be provided

Key Point: You must prove the service meets ALL five criteria. Missing even one weakens your appeal.

Common BCBS Medical Necessity Denials

Based on 5,200+ BCBS appeals analyzed through Muni Health's platform:

1. Insufficient Clinical Documentation (38%)

BCBS says: "Medical records do not support medical necessity."

This means:

• Documentation exists but doesn't demonstrate severity
• Missing baseline assessment
• No evidence of failed conservative treatments
• Treatment plan lacks specificity

Fix: Enhance documentation to show:

• Severity of condition (objective measures)
• Conservative treatments tried and failed
• Specific clinical indicators necessitating this service
• Expected outcomes with/without treatment

2. Service Not Meeting Coverage Criteria (31%)

BCBS says: "Service does not meet [BCBS company]'s Medical Policy #[X]."

This means:

• BCBS has specific criteria for coverage (e.g., "MRI only after 6 weeks of failed conservative treatment")
• Your documentation didn't prove criteria were met

Fix:

• Find the exact BCBS Medical Policy for that service
• Address each criterion explicitly
• Document how patient meets every requirement

3. Experimental or Investigational (19%)

BCBS says: "Service is considered experimental/investigational."

This means:

• BCBS considers the treatment unproven or not standard of care
• Often applies to newer treatments, medications, or procedures

Fix:

• Cite FDA approval (if applicable)
• Provide peer-reviewed studies showing efficacy
• Reference clinical practice guidelines from professional societies
• Show other BCBS plans that DO cover this service

4. Alternative Treatment Available (8%)

BCBS says: "A less costly alternative exists."

This means:

• BCBS believes a cheaper service would be equally effective
• Common for brand-name drugs when generics exist, or advanced procedures when conservative treatment hasn't been tried

Fix:

• Document why alternatives are inappropriate
• Show patient-specific factors requiring this service
• Prove alternatives were tried and failed OR
• Demonstrate why alternatives are contraindicated

5. Service Not Documented in Medical Records (4%)

BCBS says: "Service not documented."

This means:

• Service was billed but no corresponding documentation exists in submitted records
• Documentation is too vague to verify service was performed

Fix:

• Submit complete medical records
• Ensure documentation matches billed CPT codes
• Include procedure notes, operative reports, or session notes

Free BCBS Letter of Medical Necessity Template

Download and customize this Blue Cross Blue Shield medical necessity letter template for your appeals. This template works for all 34 BCBS companies - just replace the bracketed information with your patient-specific details.

How to Use This BCBS Medical Necessity Letter Template:

1. Copy the entire template below
2. Replace all [brackets] with patient-specific information
3. Identify your BCBS company (see list below) and use their specific appeal address
4. Attach required documentation: medical records, clinical guidelines, peer-reviewed studies
5. Submit within appeal deadline (typically 180 days from denial)

---

BCBS Medical Necessity Letter Template (Copy-Paste Ready)

[Your Practice Letterhead]
[Date]

[BCBS Company Name] Appeals Department
[Address - see company-specific addresses below]

RE: Medical Necessity Appeal
    Patient: [Name], DOB: [Date]
    Member ID: [BCBS ID]
    Claim Number: [Number]
    Date of Service: [Date]
    Service: [Description]
    CPT/HCPCS Code: [Code]
    Diagnosis: [ICD-10 code and description]

Dear [BCBS Company] Medical Review Team,

I am writing to appeal the denial of the above-referenced claim on the basis of
medical necessity. I respectfully disagree with the determination and provide
the following clinical justification demonstrating that [service] is medically
necessary for [patient name].

PATIENT CLINICAL PRESENTATION:

[Patient name] is a [age]-year-old [gender] with a diagnosis of [condition]
(ICD-10: [code]). Clinical presentation includes:

- Chief Complaint: [Specific symptoms]
- Duration of Symptoms: [Timeline]
- Severity: [Objective measures - pain scale, functional limitation, lab values]
- Impact on Daily Living: [Specific examples of impairment]
- Previous Treatments: [List prior interventions and outcomes]

OBJECTIVE CLINICAL FINDINGS:

[Include measurable data that demonstrates severity]

Physical Examination:
- [Specific findings, e.g., "Tenderness to palpation at L4-L5"]
- [Range of motion limitations, e.g., "Lumbar flexion limited to 30 degrees"]
- [Functional deficits, e.g., "Unable to stand longer than 5 minutes"]

Diagnostic Testing:
- [Test name and date]: [Results and clinical significance]
- [Example: "MRI lumbar spine (01/15/2025): Disc herniation L4-L5 with nerve root compression"]

Functional Assessment:
- [Standardized scores if applicable, e.g., "PHQ-9: 18 (moderately severe)"]
- [Work status: "Unable to work since [date] due to [condition]"]
- [Activities of Daily Living: "Requires assistance with bathing, dressing"]

RATIONALE FOR MEDICAL NECESSITY:

The requested service, [name service], is medically necessary for the following
reasons:

1. MEETS [BCBS COMPANY]'S COVERAGE CRITERIA

[Reference the specific BCBS Medical Policy]

Per [BCBS Company]'s Medical Policy #[number] titled "[Policy Name]," [service]
is covered when the following criteria are met:

☐ Criterion 1: [State requirement]
   Patient meets this criterion because [explanation with evidence]

☐ Criterion 2: [State requirement]
   Patient meets this criterion because [explanation with evidence]

☐ Criterion 3: [State requirement]
   Patient meets this criterion because [explanation with evidence]

[Continue for all criteria listed in the BCBS policy]

As demonstrated above, [patient name] meets ALL coverage criteria specified in
[BCBS Company]'s Medical Policy.

2. CONSERVATIVE TREATMENTS HAVE FAILED

[Required for many services - document prior treatment attempts]

The patient has undergone the following conservative treatments without
adequate symptom relief:

- [Treatment 1]: [Duration, outcome]
  Example: "Physical therapy: 8 weeks (2x/week), minimal improvement. Pain
  decreased from 8/10 to 7/10 only."

- [Treatment 2]: [Duration, outcome]
  Example: "NSAIDs (ibuprofen 800mg TID): 6 weeks, inadequate pain control,
  developed gastric upset."

- [Treatment 3]: [Duration, outcome]
  Example: "Epidural steroid injection: Temporary relief lasting only 2 weeks,
  returned to baseline pain."

Despite appropriate conservative management for [duration], the patient's
condition has [remained unchanged/worsened]. Continued conservative treatment
is unlikely to provide meaningful benefit.

3. SERVICE IS MEDICALLY APPROPRIATE AND NECESSARY

[Explain WHY this specific service is appropriate]

[Service name] is the appropriate intervention because:

a) SEVERITY OF CONDITION
   [Patient's name]'s condition has reached a severity level necessitating
   [service]. Objective evidence includes:
   - [Clinical finding demonstrating severity]
   - [Functional impairment measurement]
   - [Quality of life impact]

b) RISK OF DETERIORATION
   Without [service], the patient is at risk for:
   - [Complication 1, e.g., "progression to chronic pain syndrome"]
   - [Complication 2, e.g., "permanent functional disability"]
   - [Complication 3, e.g., "need for more invasive intervention later"]

c) EXPECTED BENEFIT
   Clinical evidence demonstrates that [service] will likely result in:
   - [Expected outcome 1, e.g., "50-70% reduction in pain scores"]
   - [Expected outcome 2, e.g., "restoration of function for work/ADLs"]
   - [Expected outcome 3, e.g., "prevention of disease progression"]

4. NO APPROPRIATE ALTERNATIVE EXISTS

[Address why other options are not suitable]

[BCBS Company] may consider less invasive alternatives such as [list potential
alternatives]. However, these are inappropriate for [patient name] because:

Alternative 1: [Name]
Reason Not Appropriate: [Clinical explanation]
Example: "Physical therapy alone: Already completed 8 weeks without benefit.
Further PT unlikely to provide additional improvement per treating physical
therapist's discharge note."

Alternative 2: [Name]
Reason Not Appropriate: [Clinical explanation]
Example: "Generic medication X: Patient has documented allergy (hives,
angioedema). Brand-name medication is medically necessary due to different
inactive ingredients."

5. EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE SUPPORTS THIS SERVICE

[Cite clinical guidelines and research]

The medical literature and clinical practice guidelines support [service] for
[patient's condition]:

- [Professional Society] Clinical Practice Guideline ([Year]) recommends
  [service] for [indication]. [Patient name]'s presentation aligns with these
  recommendations.

- [Author et al., Journal, Year] demonstrated that [service] resulted in
  [specific outcome] for patients with [condition similar to patient's].

- [Additional study/guideline citation]

Attached please find excerpts from these guidelines/studies for your review.

ALIGNMENT WITH [BCBS COMPANY] POLICIES:

This service aligns with [BCBS Company]'s definition of medical necessity as
outlined in the member contract:

1. APPROPRIATE for the condition: Yes. [Service] is standard of care for
   [condition] per [clinical guidelines].

2. PROVIDED FOR DIAGNOSIS/TREATMENT: Yes. [Service] directly addresses the
   patient's [condition] by [mechanism of action].

3. WITHIN STANDARDS OF GOOD MEDICAL PRACTICE: Yes. [Service] is endorsed by
   [professional societies] and widely accepted in the medical community.

4. NOT FOR CONVENIENCE: No. This service is being recommended purely for
   medical necessity, not patient/provider convenience.

5. MOST APPROPRIATE LEVEL OF SERVICE: Yes. Less invasive options have been
   exhausted without success. [Service] is the next appropriate step.

CLINICAL CONCLUSION:

[Patient name] requires [service] due to [brief summary]. The patient meets
[BCBS Company]'s coverage criteria, has failed appropriate conservative
treatment, and faces risk of deterioration without intervention. Denial of
this medically necessary service would be inconsistent with [BCBS Company]'s
Medical Policy #[number], accepted standards of care, and the patient's
clinical needs.

I respectfully request reconsideration of this denial and approval of [service]
for [patient name]. I am available to discuss this case via peer-to-peer
review at your convenience.

Respectfully,

[Signature]
[Provider Name, Credentials]
License #: [Number]
NPI: [Number]
Phone: [Number]
Email: [Email]

Enclosures:
☐ Complete medical records for [patient name]
☐ [BCBS Company] Medical Policy #[number] (highlighted sections showing coverage criteria)
☐ Clinical practice guidelines excerpt
☐ Peer-reviewed research abstracts
☐ Diagnostic test results (imaging reports, lab results, etc.)
☐ Previous treatment records showing failed conservative care
☐ Specialist consultation notes (if applicable)

---

---

BCBS Company-Specific Appeal Addresses

Important: Send your appeal to the correct BCBS company address.

Major BCBS Companies

Anthem BCBS (CA, CO, CT, GA, IN, KY, ME, MO, NV, NH, NY, OH, VA, WI):

Anthem BCBS Appeals
P.O. Box 105187
Atlanta, GA 30348-5187
Fax: 1-844-245-7588

Premera Blue Cross (WA, AK):

Premera Blue Cross Appeals
P.O. Box 91059
Seattle, WA 98111-9159
Fax: 1-425-918-5592

Horizon BCBS (NJ):

Horizon BCBS Appeals
P.O. Box 420
Newark, NJ 07101-0420
Fax: 1-973-466-6254

CareFirst BCBS (MD, DC, VA):

CareFirst Appeals
P.O. Box 14115
Lexington, KY 40512-4115
Fax: 1-410-581-2945

BCBS of Michigan:

BCBS Michigan Appeals
600 E. Lafayette Blvd.
Detroit, MI 48226
Fax: 1-313-225-8555

BCBS of Illinois:

BCBS Illinois Appeals
P.O. Box 804836
Chicago, IL 60680-4114
Fax: 1-312-653-6124

BCBS of Texas:

BCBS Texas Appeals
P.O. Box 660044
Dallas, TX 75266-0044
Fax: 1-972-766-8740

BCBS of Florida:

Florida Blue Appeals
P.O. Box 41405
Jacksonville, FL 32203-1405
Fax: 1-904-791-6111

For other BCBS companies, check your denial letter or call provider services.

How to Find Your BCBS Plan's Medical Policies

Each BCBS company publishes Medical Policies defining coverage criteria. You must reference the specific policy for your BCBS company.

For Anthem BCBS:

1. Go to: providers.anthem.com
2. Navigate to: Policies and Guidelines → Medical Policies
3. Search for service (e.g., "MRI lumbar spine")
4. Download PDF of current policy
5. Cite policy number and criteria in your appeal

For Other BCBS Plans:

1. Visit the BCBS company's provider website
2. Look for: "Medical Policies," "Coverage Policies," or "Clinical Guidelines"
3. Search by CPT code or service name
4. Download and cite in appeal

Strengthening Your BCBS Medical Necessity Letter

1. Use Objective Data

Weak: "Patient has back pain."

Strong: "Patient reports constant lumbar pain rated 8/10 on Visual Analog Scale, present for 14 months. Pain limits standing to 10 minutes and prevents return to work as warehouse supervisor. PHQ-9 score of 16 indicates comorbid moderate depression secondary to chronic pain and disability."

2. Show Progressive Treatment

BCBS wants to see you've tried conservative options first.

Timeline Example:

Month 1-2: NSAIDs + activity modification → No improvement
Month 3-4: Physical therapy 2x/week for 8 weeks → Minimal improvement (pain 8/10 to 7/10)
Month 5: Epidural steroid injection → Temporary relief lasting 2 weeks only
Month 6-7: Continued NSAIDs + gabapentin → Inadequate pain control, side effects
Month 8: Now requesting [advanced treatment] due to failed conservative care

This progression shows:

• Appropriate conservative management first
• Adequate trial of each treatment
• Objective measurement of outcomes
• Logical progression to advanced treatment

3. Address Cost-Effectiveness

BCBS considers cost. Show that approving your request is economically rational:

Example for Knee Replacement:

Cost of requested service (total knee arthroplasty): $25,000 (one-time)

Costs if denied (annual ongoing):
- Pain management visits: $2,400/year
- Medications: $3,600/year
- Physical therapy: $1,500/year
- Lost productivity: Unable to work
- Total annual cost: $7,500+

The requested surgery is cost-effective within 4 years and restores patient to
productive employment.

4. Include Specialist Support

If applicable, reference specialist recommendations:

Example:

Dr. [Orthopedic Surgeon], a board-certified orthopedic surgeon with 20 years
experience, evaluated [patient] on [date] and recommended [procedure] as the
medically appropriate next step. His consultation note is attached.

Specialists' recommendations carry weight, especially for complex procedures.

5. Explain Patient-Specific Factors

Generic appeals fail. Show why THIS patient needs THIS service:

Example:

While BCBS Medical Policy states [service] may not be necessary for all
patients with [diagnosis], [patient name] has unique factors warranting
approval:

1. COMORBIDITIES: Patient has diabetes and hypertension, increasing surgical
   risk if condition worsens and more invasive surgery needed later

2. OCCUPATION: Patient is a nurse requiring ability to stand/walk 8+ hours.
   Current limitation of 10 minutes standing prevents return to work.

3. AGE: At age 52, patient has 15+ productive work years ahead. Restoring
   function now prevents long-term disability costs.

4. TREATMENT RESPONSE: Patient demonstrated excellent response to diagnostic
   injection, indicating high likelihood of success with definitive treatment.

BCBS Medical Necessity Appeal FAQ

Where can I download a BCBS letter of medical necessity template?

You can copy the free BCBS medical necessity letter template above in this guide. Simply scroll up to the "BCBS Medical Necessity Letter Template (Copy-Paste Ready)" section, copy the entire template, and customize it with your patient's information. This template works for all 34 Blue Cross Blue Shield companies and has achieved an 84% success rate. No download required - just copy, customize, and submit.

Is this BCBS medical necessity letter template free to use?

Yes, this Blue Cross Blue Shield letter of medical necessity template is completely free to use for your appeals. Copy and customize it as many times as needed for your practice. For automated template generation with AI-powered clinical guideline research, try Muni Appeals (first 3 appeals free).

Can I use this template for any BCBS plan?

Yes, this BCBS medical necessity letter template works for all 34 Blue Cross Blue Shield companies including Anthem, Premera, Horizon, CareFirst, BCBS of Michigan, Illinois, Texas, Florida, and others. However, you MUST customize the template to reference your specific BCBS company's Medical Policy numbers and coverage criteria. The template structure is universal, but policy references must be plan-specific.

What should I include with my BCBS medical necessity letter?

When submitting your BCBS letter of medical necessity, include these attachments: (1) Complete medical records for the patient, (2) The BCBS Medical Policy you're referencing (highlighted sections showing coverage criteria met), (3) Clinical practice guidelines excerpt, (4) Peer-reviewed research abstracts (2-3 studies), (5) Diagnostic test results (imaging, labs), (6) Previous treatment records showing failed conservative care, and (7) Specialist consultation notes if applicable. The template above includes a checklist of all required enclosures.

How long does BCBS take to respond to appeals?

Standard: 30 days for most BCBS plans Expedited: 72 hours if you request and justify urgency Actual timeline: Most decisions in 15-25 days

Pro tip: Request expedited review if treatment delay would harm patient. Include statement: "Patient's clinical condition requires urgent decision. Continued delay will result in [specific harm]."

Can I submit the same letter to different BCBS companies?

No. Each BCBS company has different Medical Policies. You must customize your letter to reference the specific company's policies.

Example: Anthem's Medical Policy #RAD.00009 (MRI Lumbar Spine) has different criteria than BCBS of Michigan's policy for the same service.

Always check which BCBS company you're appealing to and reference THEIR policies.

What if BCBS says "lack of medical necessity" without specifics?

Request detailed denial reason:

"Dear [BCBS Company],

Regarding denied claim #[X], the denial letter states 'medical necessity not
established' but does not specify which criteria were not met or what
documentation is missing.

Please provide:
1. Which Medical Policy was applied to this denial
2. Which specific coverage criteria were not met
3. What additional documentation would support approval

This information is necessary to submit a meaningful appeal."

BCBS must provide specific rationale per federal regulations.

Should I include research studies in my appeal?

Yes, but strategically:

• Include abstracts (not full articles) of 2-3 key studies
• Highlight sections showing:
  • Efficacy of the treatment
  • Patient population similar to yours
  • Outcomes data
• Attach as separate pages (don't clutter main letter)

Most impactful studies:

1. Meta-analyses or systematic reviews
2. Randomized controlled trials
3. Studies published in high-impact journals (JAMA, NEJM, Lancet)
4. Recent studies (within last 5 years)

What if my BCBS plan is Medicare Advantage?

Key differences:

• BCBS MA plans must follow CMS coverage policies (LCDs/NCDs)
• Reference both BCBS policy AND applicable CMS coverage determination
• Shorter appeal timeline (60 days vs. 180 days for commercial)
• Can request Independent Review Entity (IRE) if denied

In your letter, cite:

• Applicable CMS Local Coverage Determination (LCD) or National Coverage Determination (NCD)
• BCBS MA plan's Medical Policy
• Show service meets BOTH CMS and BCBS criteria

Automate Your BCBS Medical Necessity Letters

Writing comprehensive medical necessity letters like this template requires 45+ minutes per appeal. For practices handling multiple BCBS denials across different plans, this becomes unmanageable.

Muni Health automates BCBS medical necessity letters with:

• 84% success rate across all 34 BCBS companies
• 5-minute generation vs. 45 minutes manual
• Automatic plan detection: Identifies which of 34 BCBS companies from denial letter
• Plan-specific policies: Cites correct Medical Policy for that BCBS company
• Evidence integration: Automatically includes relevant clinical guidelines and research

Start 3 Free BCBS Appeals →

Works with all 34 Blue Cross Blue Shield companies including Anthem, Premera, Horizon, CareFirst, and more.

---

This guide reflects 2025 BCBS medical necessity letter requirements. Requirements may vary by state and specific BCBS affiliate. Muni Appeals maintains up-to-date procedures for all 34 BCBS plans.